Yesterday, we posted our earnings press release, financial supplement, and investor presentation on the Investors section of selective.com. Our reserves remain stable across all insurance segments and lines of business, and our underlying profitability reinforces our confidence in achieving our full-year guidance. As we've emphasized in prior quarters, we continue to prioritize underwriting margins over top-line growth. Despite ongoing industry-wide reserve pressure in this segment, market pricing, particularly in other liability occurrence, has not adjusted upward.

In Standard Personal Lines, premiums declined 6%, while our target mass affluent market business grew by 1%. Our relative exposure to contractors has declined within our new business mix, reflecting our efforts to diversify and improve margin durability. We continue to invest in capabilities that support scale, diversification, and profitable growth. While we have deployed many AI tools and are evaluating more, I would like to highlight two that are having a meaningful impact in driving better, more consistent outcomes, while also improving productivity.

We also have deployed automation to support evaluation of contractual risk transfer adequacy, a key element of the underwriting process for contractors. For the quarter, we reported fully diluted EPS of $1.58 and non-GAAP operating EPS of $1.69, resulting in an 11.2% ROE and a 12% operating ROE. Importantly, we had no prior year casualty reserve development at the segment or line of business level. As a reminder, the first quarter typically runs a higher combined due to normal seasonality, and we expect our full-year underlying combined ratio to fall within our original 90.5%-91.5% range.

What went well
  • 12% operating ROE, a seventh consecutive quarter of double-digit operating returns
  • After-tax net investment income of $113 million, up 18% year-over-year, contributing 13.3 points of ROE
  • No prior-year casualty reserve development at any segment or line of business, signaling reserve stability
  • Personal Lines combined ratio improved to 92.8% from 98.0% a year earlier
  • Excess and Surplus Lines combined ratio of 89.5%, three points better than a year ago
  • Sustained pricing discipline: general liability renewal pure price up 9.8% and commercial auto pricing up 9.1%, with auto liability near 12%
  • AI claims-ingestion tool processed more than 500,000 documents and contractual-risk-transfer automation returned over 90% of results within two minutes
What went wrong
  • GAAP combined ratio of 98.3 was elevated, including a seasonally high 6.2 points of catastrophe losses
  • Total net premiums written declined about 1%, with Standard Commercial Lines down 1% and Personal Lines down 6%
  • First-quarter General Liability underlying combined ratio ran 2.3 points above full-year 2025 on embedded elevated severity
  • Standard Commercial Lines retention of 82% was down three points year-over-year due to profit-improvement actions
  • Disciplined casualty pricing hurt competitive positioning on certain casualty-oriented accounts, pressuring new business
  • Industry-wide social inflation continued to pressure general liability, commercial auto liability, and umbrella lines

More on Selective Insurance Group Inc

Reported 2026-04-23 · figures from the Selective Insurance Group Inc Q1 2026 earnings call.

See how VectorShift works for your firm

Request Demo